What do women like best; A man with money and a good job or a man with a hot body and nothing else?

Here is the scenario, you meet two guys on the street and this is what you know:

Guy Number 1:
He has a hot body.
He has a job but does not make too much money.
He is not a very good conversationalist.
He swears a lot.
He watches sports on the weekends and drinks a lot of beer.
He hangs out at the bars on Friday and Saturday nights.

Guy Number 2:
He is not bad looking, maybe a bit short.
He has a great job and house and makes a 6 figure income.
He is shy but after you get to know him, he is a good conversationalist.
He only drinks occasionally.
He would rather go to bed early on Friday and Saturday nights so he can spend time with his girlfriend on the weekends.
He does not watch sports.

So ladies, which guy would you choose? And for those of you who say, "Oh, I would pick the guy with a good job and personality" how would he start a conversation with you?

Would you even let him start a conversation with you if he came up to you at a cafe, library, or grocery store?

Yeah, definitely guy #2. He could start a conversation with me by saying "hi", or ask about a book or some produce, or whatever. But I'm married and that won't happen to me. But I can dream, can't I? Source(s): You're guy number 2, aren't you?

just depends what stage they are in life, but most of the time if the just want sex Guy #1
ooo...definitely the 2nd guy!!
well, if i was looking for fun and no strings, guy number 1. But if i was looking to make a relationship i would pick the second guy - well, actually i dont know the answer cause there has to be a certain chemistry between people, and if there isnt that its just wasting time, so it would be depend on who i fit with better through dates and stuff. i like shy guys though, but you dont know, they turn out to be freaky sometimes! (sometimes in a good way) i dunno about this question -im not into money or looks cause i know a good relationship contains more than that. . but dates, there is no harm in that - so id pick either
Is the choice really a question? Who would pick guy #1 over guy #2? I'd let him start a conversation with me, but you'd have to fight the fact that a guy who randomly approaches you in public might be a creep.
Well, in my young in fun days...guy #1 for sure!!!!

In my old and domesticated years, I would say #2- good conversation, stable life, good job, what more could a girl ask for? As for an ice breaker....say if we're at Starbucks you could offer to get me a coffee of the week to try? or you notice me studying and since you like to take college classes, you can strike up a convo about that....